Dock’s murmur

Dock’s murmur

Dock’s murmur
FeatureDescription
DefinitionA diastolic murmur heard in patients with severe coronary artery disease (CAD), especially left anterior descending (LAD) artery stenosis.
TimingEarly diastolic murmur.
LocationBest heard at the left sternal border (similar area to where aortic regurgitation is heard).
MechanismDue to relative ischemic insufficiency of the aortic valve from severe LAD disease; thought to be related to ischemia-induced dysfunction of the aortic root/valve cusp support.
Clinical importanceMimics aortic regurgitation murmur, but in the absence of valvular disease. Indicates critical coronary artery disease.
DifferentiationUnlike true aortic regurgitation, Dock’s murmur occurs without actual valve pathology; disappears after successful coronary revascularization.

Dock’s murmur

Dock’s murmur is 

a rare type of diastolic heart murmur caused by severe stenosis (narrowing) of the left anterior descending (LAD) coronary artery. The murmur, caused by turbulent blood flow, is named after Dr. William Dock, who first described it in 1967.

Characteristics

  • Timing: Diastolic, because the coronary arteries fill with blood during diastole (the relaxation phase of the cardiac cycle). It is often described as early diastolic and can have both an early and a late accentuation.
  • Sound: A high-pitched sound similar to the murmur of aortic regurgitation.
  • Location: Best heard over a very localized area at the third intercostal space, just left of the sternum.
  • Maneuver: The murmur may be audible only when the patient is sitting upright.

Association with other conditions

Dock’s murmur can occur in patients with critical LAD stenosis who also present with Wellens syndrome, a condition that involves characteristic T-wave abnormalities on an electrocardiogram (ECG) and often precedes a large anterior wall myocardial infarction.

Distinction from other murmurs

Since it resembles the murmur of aortic regurgitation, it is important for a physician to consider the patient’s other clinical signs to make the correct diagnosis. For instance, a patient with Dock’s murmur may have atypical chest pain and show T-wave abnormalities but lack a history of aortic regurgitation.

Clinical significance

Because it signals severe coronary artery disease, the discovery of Dock’s murmur should prompt immediate and further investigation, such as coronary flow imaging, to confirm the diagnosis. The murmur typically resolves following coronary artery bypass surgery to treat the stenosis.

👉 So, Dock’s murmur is essentially an ischemic functional diastolic murmur, first described by W. Dock, and is a valuable clinical clue for severe CAD.

Comparison table between Dock’s murmur and Aortic Regurgitation murmur:

FeatureDock’s MurmurAortic Regurgitation (AR) Murmur
CauseSevere coronary artery disease (especially LAD stenosis) → ischemia-induced valve cusp dysfunctionStructural aortic valve disease (rheumatic, bicuspid valve, infective endocarditis, root dilation, etc.)
TimingEarly diastolic murmurEarly diastolic murmur
Best heard atLeft sternal borderLeft sternal border, also along left 3rd–4th intercostal space, may radiate to apex
MechanismFunctional murmur due to ischemic changes in aortic root/valve supportBackflow of blood from aorta to LV due to incompetent aortic valve
Valve pathologyAbsent – murmur without structural valve lesionPresent – definite valve pathology
Associated signsNo peripheral signs of AR (e.g., no bounding pulse, no wide pulse pressure)Peripheral signs of AR often present (Corrigan’s pulse, wide pulse pressure, Quincke’s sign, etc.)
Response to treatmentDisappears after coronary revascularizationPersists until valve pathology is corrected (surgery/repair)
Clinical importanceIndicates critical CAD → warning sign for ischemiaIndicates aortic valve disease severity and progression

Q1. Dock’s murmur is most commonly associated with which underlying condition?
A. Rheumatic aortic valve disease
B. Severe coronary artery disease (LAD stenosis)
C. Mitral valve prolapse
D. Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Dock’s murmur occurs in severe CAD, particularly LAD stenosis, due to ischemic dysfunction of the aortic cusp support.

Q2. Aortic regurgitation murmur is caused by:
A. Functional ischemia without valve pathology
B. Mitral annulus calcification
C. Incompetent aortic valve
D. Pulmonary valve stenosis
Aortic regurgitation murmur results from incompetent aortic valve, allowing backflow into the left ventricle.

Q3. Dock’s murmur is best heard at which site?
A. Apex
B. Right upper sternal border
C. Pulmonic area
D. Left sternal border
Dock’s murmur is an early diastolic murmur best heard along the left sternal border, similar to AR murmur.

Q4. Which feature helps distinguish Dock’s murmur from aortic regurgitation?
A. Absence of peripheral signs of AR
B. Murmur in early diastole
C. Best heard at left sternal border
D. High-pitched blowing quality
Dock’s murmur lacks peripheral signs of AR (e.g., bounding pulse, wide pulse pressure), unlike true AR.

Q5. Which artery is most implicated in the genesis of Dock’s murmur?
A. Right coronary artery
B. Left anterior descending artery
C. Circumflex artery
D. Posterior descending artery
Severe LAD stenosis is the classical setting for Dock’s murmur.

Q6. The timing of Dock’s murmur is:
A. Mid-systolic
B. Holosystolic
C. Early diastolic
D. Mid-diastolic
Dock’s murmur is an early diastolic murmur, mimicking AR.

Q7. Which of the following peripheral signs would NOT be seen in Dock’s murmur?
A. Corrigan’s pulse
B. Quincke’s sign
C. Wide pulse pressure
D. All of the above
Dock’s murmur has no peripheral signs of AR; thus all listed signs are absent.

Q8. Dock’s murmur typically disappears after:
A. Coronary revascularization
B. Valve replacement
C. Pericardiocentesis
D. Beta-blocker therapy alone
As Dock’s murmur is ischemic, it resolves after restoring coronary perfusion by revascularization.

Q9. Aortic regurgitation murmur characteristically has which quality?
A. Rumbling low-pitched
B. Musical mid-diastolic
C. High-pitched blowing early diastolic
D. Crescendo systolic
AR murmur is classically described as a high-pitched, blowing early diastolic murmur.

Q10. Which of the following is TRUE for Dock’s murmur but not for AR murmur?
A. Best heard at left sternal border
B. No structural valve pathology
C. Early diastolic nature
D. May be high-pitched
Dock’s murmur occurs without any structural valve pathology, unlike AR.

Q11. Who first described Dock’s murmur?
A. Osler
B. Graham Steell
C. Austin Flint
D. W. Dock
Dock’s murmur was described by W. Dock as a functional diastolic murmur in severe CAD.

Q12. AR murmur often radiates to:
A. Apex
B. Carotids
C. Axilla
D. None
The AR murmur may radiate toward the apex (Cole-Cecil murmur may be heard at apex).

Q13. Dock’s murmur is considered:
A. Innocent murmur
B. Congenital murmur
C. Functional murmur
D. Structural murmur
Dock’s murmur is a functional murmur, secondary to ischemia, without structural valve disease.

Q14. In AR, which pulse finding is typical?
A. Bounding or water-hammer pulse
B. Slow-rising pulse
C. Pulsus paradoxus
D. Pulsus alternans
A bounding, water-hammer pulse is characteristic of AR due to increased stroke volume and rapid diastolic runoff.

Q15. Which investigation confirms absence of valve pathology in Dock’s murmur?
A. ECG
B. Chest X-ray
C. Cardiac enzymes
D. Echocardiography
Echocardiography confirms the absence of structural aortic valve disease in Dock’s murmur.

Q16. Dock’s murmur is clinically significant because it indicates:
A. Mild coronary artery disease
B. Critical coronary artery disease
C. Mild pulmonary hypertension
D. Benign innocent murmur
Dock’s murmur is a clinical clue for critical CAD, requiring urgent attention.

Q17. Which statement is TRUE regarding AR murmur?
A. Always disappears after revascularization
B. Has no associated signs
C. Persists until valve disease corrected
D. Heard only during systole
AR murmur persists until the structural valve pathology is corrected surgically or otherwise.

Q18. Dock’s murmur most closely mimics which murmur?
A. Aortic regurgitation murmur
B. Mitral stenosis murmur
C. Pulmonic stenosis murmur
D. Tricuspid regurgitation murmur
Dock’s murmur mimics AR murmur in timing and location but without valve disease.

Q19. Which maneuver typically increases AR murmur intensity?
A. Inspiration
B. Valsalva
C. Standing
D. Handgrip
Handgrip increases afterload and intensifies AR murmur by increasing regurgitant flow.

Q20. In Dock’s murmur, which of the following is absent compared to true AR?
A. Early diastolic timing
B. Wide pulse pressure
C. Left sternal border location
D. High-pitched nature
Dock’s murmur does not produce wide pulse pressure, which is a classic feature of true AR.
    Subscribe Medicine Question BankWhatsApp Channel

    FREE Updates, MCQs & Questions For Doctors & Medical Students

      Medicine Question Bank